Share
VIDEOS 1 TO 50
Plato
Plato's Cratylus -- Brief Introduction
Published: 2015/12/01
Channel: WiseCounselResearch
Cratylus by Plato: A Summary
Cratylus by Plato: A Summary
Published: 2016/06/16
Channel: LongHairedFreakyDude
Cratylus PLATO (ΠΛΆΤΩΝ) audiobook
Cratylus PLATO (ΠΛΆΤΩΝ) audiobook
Published: 2015/02/08
Channel: Talking Books
Cratylus by Plato (1 of 2) (audiobook)
Cratylus by Plato (1 of 2) (audiobook)
Published: 2014/09/15
Channel: The 16th Cavern
Cratylus "Line and Reason"
Cratylus "Line and Reason"
Published: 2016/06/30
Channel: Fullness of Meaning Christian Ministries
Plato
Plato's Theaetetus -- Brief Introduction
Published: 2015/05/05
Channel: WiseCounselResearch
Theaetetus (dialogue)
Theaetetus (dialogue)
Published: 2016/01/22
Channel: WikiAudio
Cratylus by Plato (2 of 2) (audiobook)
Cratylus by Plato (2 of 2) (audiobook)
Published: 2014/09/15
Channel: The 16th Cavern
Cratylus, by Plato, Philosophy Audiobook, Greek Philosophy
Cratylus, by Plato, Philosophy Audiobook, Greek Philosophy
Published: 2014/07/27
Channel: Audiobooks CC
The letters of Marsilio  Ficino(1433-1499), Volume 1 letters 1-13
The letters of Marsilio Ficino(1433-1499), Volume 1 letters 1-13
Published: 2014/08/10
Channel: Joe Kiernan
Plato
Plato's Dialogue - The Ion - Poetry, Interpretation, Emotion, and Knowledge
Published: 2014/01/18
Channel: Gregory B. Sadler
What is SOPHISM? What does SOPHISM mean? SOPHISM meaning, definition & explanation
What is SOPHISM? What does SOPHISM mean? SOPHISM meaning, definition & explanation
Published: 2017/08/18
Channel: The Audiopedia
Cratylus Full Audiobook by PLATO (ΠΛΆΤΩΝ) by Writing & Linguistics, Ancient
Cratylus Full Audiobook by PLATO (ΠΛΆΤΩΝ) by Writing & Linguistics, Ancient
Published: 2015/12/01
Channel: Full Audiobooks
Ion; on the Nature of Art, Philosophy Audiobook by Plato, Classic Greek Philosopher
Ion; on the Nature of Art, Philosophy Audiobook by Plato, Classic Greek Philosopher
Published: 2014/03/26
Channel: Free Audio Books for Intellectual Exercise
Plato
Plato's Lysis in 60 Seconds
Published: 2016/01/10
Channel: 60Second Philosophy
Cratylus
Cratylus
Published: 2016/11/05
Channel: Altanesta
Hippias Major by Plato
Hippias Major by Plato
Published: 2016/07/12
Channel: Geoffrey Edwards
How to Pronounce Cratylus
How to Pronounce Cratylus
Published: 2012/12/26
Channel: Emma Saying
The Great Books Challenge!
The Great Books Challenge!
Published: 2015/07/28
Channel: LongHairedFreakyDude
Poetry and Divine Inspiration in Plato
Poetry and Divine Inspiration in Plato's Ion - Philosophy Core Concepts
Published: 2014/02/05
Channel: Gregory B. Sadler
Ion by PLATO (FULL Audiobook)
Ion by PLATO (FULL Audiobook)
Published: 2013/12/10
Channel: FULL audio books for everyone
Protagoras by Plato: A Summary
Protagoras by Plato: A Summary
Published: 2016/04/07
Channel: LongHairedFreakyDude
Stafylakis - Never the Same River (2013)
Stafylakis - Never the Same River (2013)
Published: 2015/02/22
Channel: Harry Stafylakis
Plato Cratylus  Parmenides  Greater Hippias  Lesser Hippias  Loeb Classical Library No  167
Plato Cratylus Parmenides Greater Hippias Lesser Hippias Loeb Classical Library No 167
Published: 2016/05/13
Channel: Gertrude Sargent
Harry Stafylakis: Never the Same River
Harry Stafylakis: Never the Same River
Published: 2015/03/31
Channel: Ensemble 212
Protagoras, by Plato
Protagoras, by Plato
Published: 2016/04/02
Channel: LibriVox - Audiobooks
Dr. John Rist: The Role of Plato in the Academy
Dr. John Rist: The Role of Plato in the Academy
Published: 2013/08/18
Channel: Franciscan University of Steubenville
W. T. Stace. A Critical History of Greek Philosophy. Aristotle
W. T. Stace. A Critical History of Greek Philosophy. Aristotle
Published: 2014/05/12
Channel: Ilya Stepanov
Euthyphro   Socratic Dialogues   Plato
Euthyphro Socratic Dialogues Plato
Published: 2016/04/29
Channel: hats0fyou
Euthydemus by Plato
Euthydemus by Plato
Published: 2016/07/12
Channel: Geoffrey Edwards
Meno by Plato (audiobook)
Meno by Plato (audiobook)
Published: 2013/09/30
Channel: The 16th Cavern
What is PLATO
What is PLATO'S PROBLEM? What does PLATO'S PROBLEM mean? PLATO'S PROBLEM meaning
Published: 2016/12/02
Channel: The Audiopedia
Eryxias- Full AudioBook - English - Unabridged - Business & Economics, Ancient
Eryxias- Full AudioBook - English - Unabridged - Business & Economics, Ancient
Published: 2014/11/10
Channel: GreatAudioBooks In Public Domain
Charmides by Plato (audiobook)
Charmides by Plato (audiobook)
Published: 2015/09/08
Channel: The 16th Cavern
Charmides by Plato: A Summary
Charmides by Plato: A Summary
Published: 2015/08/10
Channel: LongHairedFreakyDude
Lysis by Plato
Lysis by Plato
Published: 2016/07/12
Channel: Geoffrey Edwards
Eryxias By Plato [ FULL AUDIOBOOK ]
Eryxias By Plato [ FULL AUDIOBOOK ]
Published: 2016/05/18
Channel: AudioBooks For Success, Money & Wealth
Clitopho by Plato
Clitopho by Plato
Published: 2016/07/12
Channel: Geoffrey Edwards
Laches by Plato
Laches by Plato
Published: 2016/07/12
Channel: Geoffrey Edwards
Charmidea
Charmidea
Published: 2011/02/26
Channel: Alencia Lysander
The Apology of Socrates (Ancient Greek) PLATO (ΠΛΆΤΩΝ)
The Apology of Socrates (Ancient Greek) PLATO (ΠΛΆΤΩΝ)
Published: 2016/09/11
Channel: Audio Books Free Download
Plato — Symposium {audiobook}
Plato — Symposium {audiobook}
Published: 2015/03/24
Channel: Free Ebooks
Euthyphro Full Audiobook by PLATO by Ancient Audiobooks
Euthyphro Full Audiobook by PLATO by Ancient Audiobooks
Published: 2015/11/16
Channel: Full Audiobooks
Wise Demons
Wise Demons
Published: 2007/12/24
Channel: HaleyMary
Sophist   Full AudioBook   by Plato
Sophist Full AudioBook by Plato
Published: 2015/03/25
Channel: Free Ebooks
Charmides by Plato
Charmides by Plato
Published: 2016/07/12
Channel: Geoffrey Edwards
Ion by Plato [Full Audiobook]
Ion by Plato [Full Audiobook]
Published: 2015/12/08
Channel: Free Ebooks
Phaedrus by Plato (audiobook)
Phaedrus by Plato (audiobook)
Published: 2013/10/02
Channel: The 16th Cavern
The Mistress of the Inn, Italian Comedy Audiobook, La Locandiera, by Carlo Goldoni
The Mistress of the Inn, Italian Comedy Audiobook, La Locandiera, by Carlo Goldoni
Published: 2014/09/05
Channel: Free Audio Books for Intellectual Exercise
Critias
Critias
Published: 2016/11/05
Channel: Altanesta
NEXT
GO TO RESULTS [51 .. 100]

WIKIPEDIA ARTICLE

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Cratylus (/krəˈtləs/; Ancient Greek: Κρατύλος, Kratylos) is the name of a dialogue by Plato. Most modern scholars agree that it was written mostly during Plato's so-called middle period.[1] In the dialogue, Socrates is asked by two men, Cratylus and Hermogenes, to tell them whether names are "conventional" or "natural", that is, whether language is a system of arbitrary signs or whether words have an intrinsic relation to the things they signify.

The individual Cratylus was the first intellectual influence on Plato (Sedley).[2] Aristotle states that Cratylus influenced Plato by introducing to him the teachings of Heraclitus, according to MW. Riley.[3][4]

Summary[edit]

The subject of Cratylus is the correctness of names (περὶ ὀνομάτων ὀρθότητος),[5] in other words, it is a critique on the subject of naming (Baxter).[6]

When discussing a ὄνομα [7] (onoma [8][9][10]) and how it would relate to its subject, Socrates compares the original creation of a word to the work of an artist.[11] An artist uses color to express the essence of his subject in a painting. In much the same way, the creator of words uses letters containing certain sounds to express the essence of a word's subject. There is a letter that is best for soft things, one for liquid things, and so on.[12] He comments;[13]

the best possible way to speak consists in using names all (or most) of which are like the things they name (that is, are appropriate to them), while the worst is to use the opposite kind of names.

One countering position, held by Hermogenes, is that names have come about due to custom and convention. They do not express the essence of their subject, so they can be swapped with something unrelated by the individuals or communities who use them.[14]

The line between the two perspectives is often blurred.[clarification needed] During more than half of the dialogue, Socrates makes guesses at Hermogenes' request as to where names and words have come from. These include the names of the Olympian gods, personified deities, and many words that describe abstract concepts. He examines whether, for example, giving names of "streams" to Cronus and Rhea (Ροή – flow or space) are purely accidental.

Don't you think he who gave to the ancestors of the other gods the names “Rhea” and “Cronus” had the same thought as Heracleitus? Do you think he gave both of them the names of streams (ῥευμάτων ὀνόματα) merely by chance?[15]

The Greek term "ῥεῦμα" may refer to the flow of any medium and is not restricted to the flow of water or liquids.[16] Many of the words which Socrates uses as examples may have come from an idea originally linked to the name, but have changed over time. Those of which he cannot find a link, he often assumes have come from foreign origins or have changed so much as to lose all resemblance to the original word. He states, "names have been so twisted in all manner of ways, that I should not be surprised if the old language when compared with that now in use would appear to us to be a barbarous tongue."[17]

The final theory of relations between name and object named is posited by Cratylus, a disciple of Heraclitus, who believes that names arrive from divine origins, making them necessarily correct. Socrates rebukes this theory by reminding Cratylus of the imperfection of certain names in capturing the objects they seek to signify. From this point, Socrates ultimately rejects the study of language, believing it to be philosophically inferior to a study of things themselves.

Appropriate sounds[edit]

  • ρ ('r') is a "tool for copying every sort of motion (κίνησις)."[18][foot 1]
  • ι ('i') for imitating "all the small things that can most easily penetrate everything",[19][foot 2]
  • φ ('phi'), ψ ('psi'). σ ('s'), and ζ ('z') as "all these letters are pronounced with an expulsion of breath", they are most appropriate for imitating "blowing or hard breathing".[20][foot 3]
  • δ ('d') and τ ('t') as both involve "compression and [the] stopping of the power of the tongue" when pronounced, they are most appropriate for words indicating a lack or stopping of motion.[20][21][foot 4]
  • λ ('l'), as "the tongue glides most of all" when pronounced, it is most appropriate for words denoting a sort of gliding.[21][foot 5]
  • γ ('g') best used when imitating "something cloying", as the gliding of the tongue is stopped when pronounced.[21][foot 6]
  • ν ('n') best used when imitating inward things, as it is "sounded inwardly".[21][22][foot 7]
  • α ('a'), η ('long e') best used when imitating large things, as they are both "pronounced long".[22][foot 8]
  • ο ('o') best used when imitating roundness.[22][foot 9]

Although these are clear examples of onomatopoeia, Socrates's statement that words are not musical imitations of the nature suggests that Plato didn't believe that language itself generates from sound words.[23]

Platonic Theory of Forms[edit]

Plato's theory of forms also makes an appearance. For example, no matter what a hammer is made out of, it is still called a "hammer", and thus is the form of a hammer:

Socrates: So mustn't a rule-setter also know how to embody in sounds and syllables the name naturally suited to each thing? And if he is to be an authentic giver of names, mustn't he, in making and giving each name, look to what a name itself is? And if different rule-setters do not make each name out of the same syllables, we mustn't forget that different blacksmiths, who are making the same tool for the same type of work, don't all make it out of the same iron. But as long as they give it the same form--even if that form is embodied in different iron--the tool will be correct, whether it is made in Greece or abroad. Isn't that so?[24]

Plato's theory of forms again appears at 439c, when Cratylus concedes the existence of "a beautiful itself, and a good itself, and the same for each one of the things that are".[25]

Translations[edit]

The I.Bekker edition was published 1826 (London) under the heading Platonis Scripta Graece Omnia.[26]

A translation was made by H. N. Fowler and published during 1926 under Loeb Classical Library by Harvard University Press.[27]

See also[edit]

Footnotes[edit]

  1. ^ e.g. rhein ('flowing'), rhoe ('flow'), tromos ('trembling'), trechein ('running'), krouein ('striking'), thrauein ('crushing'), ereikein ('rending'), thruptein ('breaking'), kermatizein ('crumbling'), rhumbein ('whirling').
  2. ^ e.g. ienai ('moving'), hiesthai ('hastening').
  3. ^ e.g. psuchron ('chilling'), zeon ('seething'), seiesthai ('shaking'), seismos ('quaking').
  4. ^ e.g. desmos ('shackling'), stasis ('rest').
  5. ^ e.g. olisthanein ('glide'), leion ('smooth'), liparon ('sleek'), kollodes ('viscous').
  6. ^ e.g. glischron ('gluey'), gluku ('sweet'), gloiodes ('clammy').
  7. ^ e.g. endon ('within'), entos ('inside').
  8. ^ e.g. mega ('large'), mekos ('length').
  9. ^ e.g. gongulon ('round').

References[edit]

  1. ^ pp. 6, 13-14, David Sedley, Plato's Cratylus, Cambridge U Press 2003.
  2. ^ D Sedley (Laurence Professor of Ancient Philosophy in the University of Cambridge) - Plato's Cratylus (p.2) Cambridge University Press, 6 Nov 2003 ISBN 1139439197 [Retrieved 2015-3-26]
  3. ^ MW. Riley (Professor of Classics and Tutor, formerly Director, of the Integral Liberal Arts Program at Saint Mary's College in Moraga, California c.2005) - Plato's Cratylus: Argument, Form, and Structure (p.29) Publication:Rodopi, 1 Jan 2005 [Retrieved 2015-3-27]
  4. ^ (ed. no part of this reference was used in the adding of material to this article [Retrieved 2015-3-27]
  5. ^ F Ademollo (studied classics at the University of Florence and has held postdoctoral research positions at the University of Florence and at the Scuola Normale Superiore) - The Cratylus of Plato: A Commentary (p.I) Cambridge University Press, 3 Feb 2011 ISBN 1139494694 [Retrieved 2015-3-26]
  6. ^ T M. S. Baxter (holds a Ph.D. in Ancient Philosophy from the University of Cambridge) - The Cratylus: Plato's Critique of Naming Volume 58 of Philosophia Antiqua : A Series of Studies on Ancient Philosophy BRILL, 1992 ISBN 9004095977 [Retrieved 2015-3-26]
  7. ^ Perseus - Latin Word Study Tool - onoma Tufts University [Retrieved 2015-3-20]
  8. ^ AC Yu - Early China/Ancient Greece: Thinking through Comparisons (edited by S Shankman, SW Durrant) SUNY Press, 1 Feb 2012 ISBN 0791488942 [Retrieved 2015-3-20]
  9. ^ Cratylus - Translated by Benjamin Jowett [Retrieved 2015-3-20]
  10. ^ Strong's Concordance - onoma Bible Hub (ed. used as secondary verification of onoma)
  11. ^ Cratylus 390d-e.
  12. ^ Cratylus 431d.
  13. ^ Cratylus 435c.
  14. ^ Cratylus 383a-b.
  15. ^ Cratylus 402b
  16. ^ Entry ῥεῦμα at LSJ. Besides the flow liquids, "ῥεῦμα" may refer to the flow of sound (Epicurus,Ep. 1p.13U), to the flow of fortune etc.
  17. ^ Cratylus 421d
  18. ^ Cratylus 426c-e.
  19. ^ Cratylus 426e-427a.
  20. ^ a b Cratylus 427a.
  21. ^ a b c d Cratylus 427b.
  22. ^ a b c Cratylus 427c.
  23. ^ Claramonte, Manuel Breva (1983). Sanctius Theory of Language: A Contribution to the History of Renaissance Linguistic. John Benjamins Publishing, p. 24. ISBN 9027245053
  24. ^ Cratylus 389d-390a1.
  25. ^ Cratylus 439c-d.
  26. ^ F Ademollo. The Cratylus of Plato: A Commentary (xvii). Cambridge University Press, 3 Feb 2011 ISBN 1139494694. Retrieved 2015-05-10. 
  27. ^ Sedley, D. Plato's Cratylus. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2013 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.). Retrieved 2015-05-10. 

External links[edit]

Disclaimer

None of the audio/visual content is hosted on this site. All media is embedded from other sites such as GoogleVideo, Wikipedia, YouTube etc. Therefore, this site has no control over the copyright issues of the streaming media.

All issues concerning copyright violations should be aimed at the sites hosting the material. This site does not host any of the streaming media and the owner has not uploaded any of the material to the video hosting servers. Anyone can find the same content on Google Video or YouTube by themselves.

The owner of this site cannot know which documentaries are in public domain, which has been uploaded to e.g. YouTube by the owner and which has been uploaded without permission. The copyright owner must contact the source if he wants his material off the Internet completely.

Powered by YouTube
Wikipedia content is licensed under the GFDL and (CC) license