Play Video
1
Debate: Vegan vs Vegan (Gary Francione vs Bruce Friedrich)
Debate: Vegan vs Vegan (Gary Francione vs Bruce Friedrich)
::2013/07/27::
Play Video
2
Gary L. Francione - How to Get People to Think about Veganism
Gary L. Francione - How to Get People to Think about Veganism
::2014/02/21::
Play Video
3
Animals as Food? - Keynote Speech - Vegan Prof. Gary L. Francione
Animals as Food? - Keynote Speech - Vegan Prof. Gary L. Francione
::2013/12/22::
Play Video
4
Vegan Series: Eat Like You Care featuring Gary L. Francione & Anna Charlton
Vegan Series: Eat Like You Care featuring Gary L. Francione & Anna Charlton
::2014/04/17::
Play Video
5
Gary L. Francione Destroys the Idea that Plants Feel Pain
Gary L. Francione Destroys the Idea that Plants Feel Pain
::2014/05/29::
Play Video
6
Appropriation of Abolition and Animal Rights by Regulationists, Gary Francione IARC 2013 Luxembourg
Appropriation of Abolition and Animal Rights by Regulationists, Gary Francione IARC 2013 Luxembourg
::2013/09/15::
Play Video
7
Gary Francione Interview Part I
Gary Francione Interview Part I
::2009/11/01::
Play Video
8
Vegan Freak Radio Podcast - Interview with Gary L. Francione (2006-11-03)
Vegan Freak Radio Podcast - Interview with Gary L. Francione (2006-11-03)
::2011/12/10::
Play Video
9
13a The Kevin Storm Show w/Gary L. Francione Part 1/2
13a The Kevin Storm Show w/Gary L. Francione Part 1/2
::2013/06/04::
Play Video
10
Animales como Propiedad - Gary L. Francione
Animales como Propiedad - Gary L. Francione
::2008/01/14::
Play Video
11
Vegan Freak Radio #095 - Interview with Gary L. Francione (Part 2 of 2)
Vegan Freak Radio #095 - Interview with Gary L. Francione (Part 2 of 2)
::2011/12/10::
Play Video
12
Animales como Propiedad - Gary L. Francione
Animales como Propiedad - Gary L. Francione
::2008/03/08::
Play Video
13
Vegan Freak Radio #094 - Interview with Gary L. Francione (Part 1 of 2)
Vegan Freak Radio #094 - Interview with Gary L. Francione (Part 1 of 2)
::2011/12/10::
Play Video
14
Sociedade Veganismo *VALE DO TAQUARI*: Gary L. Francione!
Sociedade Veganismo *VALE DO TAQUARI*: Gary L. Francione!
::2013/07/25::
Play Video
15
Gary Francione on Animal Abolition & Ethical Consumption
Gary Francione on Animal Abolition & Ethical Consumption
::2013/12/12::
Play Video
16
Interview with Gary Francione Part II
Interview with Gary Francione Part II
::2009/11/04::
Play Video
17
GARY FRANCIONE - The Abolitionist Approach
GARY FRANCIONE - The Abolitionist Approach
::2014/06/19::
Play Video
18
Interview with Gary Francione Part IV
Interview with Gary Francione Part IV
::2009/11/07::
Play Video
19
Interview with Gary Francione Part III
Interview with Gary Francione Part III
::2009/11/07::
Play Video
20
Interview with Gary Francione Part V
Interview with Gary Francione Part V
::2009/12/01::
Play Video
21
Interview with Gary Francione Part VI
Interview with Gary Francione Part VI
::2009/12/01::
Play Video
22
13b The Kevin Storm Show w/guest Gary Francione Part 2/2
13b The Kevin Storm Show w/guest Gary Francione Part 2/2
::2013/06/04::
Play Video
23
Interview with Gary Francione Part VII
Interview with Gary Francione Part VII
::2009/12/01::
Play Video
24
Animals in Biomedical Research: A Moral Justification? (debate)
Animals in Biomedical Research: A Moral Justification? (debate)
::2012/12/23::
Play Video
25
The Lawsuits of the CULT OF FRANCIONE (Gary L)
The Lawsuits of the CULT OF FRANCIONE (Gary L)
::2010/03/20::
Play Video
26
Animals as Property (EN)
Animals as Property (EN)
::2014/08/20::
Play Video
27
Gary Francione
Gary Francione
::2013/06/23::
Play Video
28
Gary Francione on animal ethics
Gary Francione on animal ethics
::2014/05/29::
Play Video
29
Everything I Ate Today + Why People Ignore Advice
Everything I Ate Today + Why People Ignore Advice
::2014/06/26::
Play Video
30
I
I'm Vegan: Gary Francione
::2011/04/29::
Play Video
31
Professor Francione Debates Professor Tibor Machan: “Do Animals Have Rights?” (EN)
Professor Francione Debates Professor Tibor Machan: “Do Animals Have Rights?” (EN)
::2014/08/21::
Play Video
32
RGB Vegan: Intro to Animal Rights
RGB Vegan: Intro to Animal Rights
::2014/05/13::
Play Video
33
Droits des animaux − vs − bien-être animal (FR)
Droits des animaux − vs − bien-être animal (FR)
::2014/08/20::
Play Video
34
Animals as Property Dieren als Eigendommen (NL)
Animals as Property Dieren als Eigendommen (NL)
::2014/08/23::
Play Video
35
Direitos animais vs  bem estar animal (PT)
Direitos animais vs bem estar animal (PT)
::2014/08/21::
Play Video
36
Tierrechte vs  Tierschutz (DE)
Tierrechte vs Tierschutz (DE)
::2014/08/21::
Play Video
37
A Closer Look at Animal Rights (EN)
A Closer Look at Animal Rights (EN)
::2014/08/20::
Play Video
38
Animales como propiedad (ES)
Animales como propiedad (ES)
::2014/08/20::
Play Video
39
The Use of Animals in Biomedical Research  A Moral Justification (EN)
The Use of Animals in Biomedical Research A Moral Justification (EN)
::2014/08/20::
Play Video
40
¡Hola Youtube!  Una vegana abolitionista se presenta a su mundo
¡Hola Youtube! Una vegana abolitionista se presenta a su mundo
::2013/01/07::
Play Video
41
Gary Francione at Brock U. Part 1/5
Gary Francione at Brock U. Part 1/5
::2014/03/30::
Play Video
42
OSLOBOĐENJE ŽIVOTINJA - abolicionizam, veganstvo, nespecizam (4. emisija)
OSLOBOĐENJE ŽIVOTINJA - abolicionizam, veganstvo, nespecizam (4. emisija)
::2012/10/01::
Play Video
43
Live and Let Live - Clip - Gary Francione
Live and Let Live - Clip - Gary Francione
::2014/05/11::
Play Video
44
Drawing the Line (Gary Francione)
Drawing the Line (Gary Francione)
::2013/11/01::
Play Video
45
2. Animals as Property
2. Animals as Property
::2009/01/14::
Play Video
46
Gary Francione & Bruce Friedrich discuss Francione
Gary Francione & Bruce Friedrich discuss Francione's animal rights theories (abolitionist approach)
::2013/07/06::
Play Video
47
Pt 8 Talking With Non-Vegans About Veganism: 5 Principles
Pt 8 Talking With Non-Vegans About Veganism: 5 Principles
::2011/09/03::
Play Video
48
Direitos animais vs. bem-estar animal 1/2
Direitos animais vs. bem-estar animal 1/2
::2009/11/16::
Play Video
49
Pt 9 Talking With Non-Vegans About Veganism: 5 Principles
Pt 9 Talking With Non-Vegans About Veganism: 5 Principles
::2011/09/03::
Play Video
50
Hi YouTube! An abolitionist vegan advocate introducing myself to your world
Hi YouTube! An abolitionist vegan advocate introducing myself to your world
::2013/01/07::
NEXT >>
RESULTS [51 .. 101]
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Gary Francione
photograph
Gary Francione with Mollie and Katie,
who were rescued from a shelter
Born May 1954 (age 60)
Education BA in philosophy, University of Rochester
MA in philosophy, and JD, University of Virginia
Occupation Distinguished Professor of Law and Nicholas deB. Katzenbach Scholar of Law & Philosophy, Rutgers School of Law–Newark
Known for Animal rights advocacy
Website

Animal Rights: The Abolitionist Approach

Video of Francione speaking about veganism, 2009

Gary Lawrence Francione (born May 1954) is an American legal scholar. He is the Distinguished Professor of Law and Nicholas deB. Katzenbach Scholar of Law & Philosophy at Rutgers School of Law–Newark.[1]

Francione is known for his work on animal rights theory, and was the first academic to teach it in an American law school.[2] His work has focused on three issues: the property status of animals, the differences between animal rights and animal welfare, and a theory of animal rights based on sentience alone, rather than on any other cognitive characteristics.

He is a pioneer of the abolitionist theory of animal rights, arguing that animal welfare regulation is theoretically and practically unsound, serving only to prolong the status of animals as property by making the public feel comfortable about using them.[3] He argues that non-human animals require only one right, the right not to be regarded as property, and that ethical veganism – the rejection of the use of animal products – is the moral baseline of the animal rights movement. He rejects all forms of violence, arguing that the animal rights movement is the logical progression of the peace movement, seeking to take it one step further by ending conflict between human and non-human animals, and by treating animals as ends in themselves.[4]

Francione is the author or co-author of several books about animal rights, including The Animal Rights Debate: Abolition or Regulation? (2010, with Robert Garner), Animals as Persons (2008), Rain Without Thunder: The Ideology of the Animal Rights Movement (1996), and Animals, Property, and the Law (1995). He has also written papers on copyright, patent law, and law and science.

Background[edit]

Francione graduated with a BA in philosophy from the University of Rochester, where he was awarded the Phi Beta Kappa O'Hearn Scholarship, allowing him to pursue graduate study in philosophy in the UK. He received his MA in philosophy and his JD from the University of Virginia, where he was articles editor of the Virginia Law Review. After graduation, he clerked for Judge Albert Tate, Jr., U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, and for Justice Sandra Day O'Connor of the U.S. Supreme Court.[1]

After practising law at the New York firm Cravath, Swaine & Moore, he joined the faculty at the University of Pennsylvania Law School in 1984, and received tenure in 1987. He began to teach animal rights theory as part of his course in jurisprudence in 1985. In 1989, he joined the Rutgers faculty, and in 1990, he and his colleague Anna E. Charlton started the Rutgers Animal Rights Law Project, in which law students were awarded academic credit for working on actual cases involving animals. Francione and Charlton closed the clinic in 2000, but continue to teach courses in animal rights theory, animals and the law, and human rights and animal rights. Francione also teaches criminal law, criminal procedure, and legal philosophy.[1]

Animal rights theory[edit]

Property status of animals[edit]

In Animals, Property, and the Law (1995), Francione argues that because animals are the property of humans, laws that supposedly require their "humane" treatment and prohibit the infliction of "unnecessary" harm do not provide a significant level of protection for animal interests. For the most part, these laws and regulations require only that animals receive that level of protection that is required for their use as human property. Animals only have value as commodities and their interests do not matter in any moral sense. As a result, despite having laws that supposedly protect them, Francione contends that we treat animals in ways that would be regarded as torture if humans were involved. He argues that we could choose to provide greater protection to animals even if they were to remain our property, but legal, social, and economic forces militate strongly against recognizing animal interests unless there is an economic benefit to humans.

Comparison of animal rights and animal welfare[edit]

Further information: Abolitionism (animal rights)

In Rain Without Thunder: The Ideology of the Animal Rights Movement (1996), Francione argues that there are significant theoretical and practical differences between animal rights, which he maintains requires the abolition of animal exploitation, and animal welfare, which seeks to regulate exploitation to make it more humane. Francione contends that the theoretical difference between these two approaches is obvious. The abolitionist position is that we cannot justify our use of nonhumans however “humanely” we treat animals; the regulationist position is that animal use is justifiable and that only issues of treatment are relevant.

Francione describes as "new welfarists" those who claim to support animal rights, but who support animal welfare regulation as the primary way to achieve incremental recognition of the inherent value of nonhumans. He argues that there is no factual support for this position because not only do regulations seldom if ever go beyond treating animals as economic commodities with only extrinsic value, but the perception that regulation has improved the "humane" treatment of animals may very well facilitate continued and increased exploitation by making the public feel more comfortable about its consumption of animal products.

A central tenet of Francione's philosophy is that the most important form of incremental change within the abolitionist framework is veganism. Francione has also long argued that the animal rights movement is the logical extension of the peace movement and should embrace a non-violent approach. He maintains that an abolitionist/vegan movement is truly radical and that violence is reactionary.

Relevance of sentience[edit]

In his Introduction to Animal Rights: Your Child or the Dog? (2000), Francione argues that a theory of abolition should not require that animals have any cognitive characteristic beyond sentience to be full members of the moral community, entitled to the basic, pre-legal right not to be the property of humans. He rejects the position that animals have to have humanlike cognitive characteristics, such as reflective self-awareness, language ability, or preference autonomy in order to have the right not to be used as human resources. Francione derives this right from the principle of equal consideration in that he maintains that if animals are property, their interests can never receive equal consideration.

As part of this discussion, Francione identifies what he calls our “moral schizophrenia” when it comes to nonhumans. On the one hand, we say that we take animal interests seriously. Francione points to the fact that many of us even live with nonhuman companions whom we regard as members of our families and whose personhood—their status as beings with intrinsic moral value—we do not doubt for a second. On the other hand, because animals are property, they remain things that have no value other than what we choose to accord them and whose interests we protect only when it provides a benefit—usually economic—to do so. According to Francione, if animals are going to matter morally and not be things, we cannot treat them as property. Francione debated the sentience of plants with Michael Marder in a debate organized by Columbia University Press.[5]

Animal rights movement[edit]

Further information: Animal liberation movement

Francione is strongly opposed to the ideological support of animal welfarist organisations such as PETA. He claims these groups condone the continued exploitation of animals through supporting isolated improvements in animal welfare and 'happy meat'. Contrary to reducing the harm imposed upon animals, Francione argues this support of meat products leads consumers to further justify their consumption of unethical food products as they believe such an action is morally permissible or helpful.

In 2008, Francione opposed California's Proposition 2, which was a ballot proposition to prohibit the confinement of certain farm animals in a manner that does not allow them to turn around freely, lie down, stand up, and fully extend their limbs.[6]

Francione’s theory of animal rights, particularly his views on animal welfare, is criticized by some sections of the animal protection movement, who argue that animal welfare does provide meaningful protection for animal interests. Moreover, many within the animal protection community maintain that certain animals, such as the great apes or dolphins, ought to receive greater protection based only on their cognitive similarity to humans—the so-called "similar minds position"—a position Francione has opposed:

I certainly agree that it is wrong to use nonhuman great apes in research or in circuses, or to confine them in zoos, or to use them for any other purpose. But I reject what I call the "similar minds" position that links the moral status of nonhumans to their possession of humanlike cognitive characteristics. The exploitation of the nonhuman great apes is immoral for the same reason that is immoral to exploit the hundreds of millions of mice and rats who are routinely exploited in laboratories or the billions of nonhumans who we kill and eat: the nonhuman great apes and all of these other nonhumans are, like us, sentient. They are conscious; they are subjectively aware; they have interests; they can suffer. No characteristic other than sentience is required for personhood."[7]

Bibliography[edit]

  • "Eat Like You Care: An Examination of the Morality of Eating Animals". Exempla Press, 2013. ISBN 978-1-492-38651-3.
  • The Animal Rights Debate: Abolition or Regulation. Columbia University Press, 2010. ISBN 978-0-231-14955-6
  • "Animal Welfare and the Moral Value of Nonhuman Animals." Law, Culture and the Humanities 6(1), 2009: 24-36.
  • Animals As Persons: Essays on the Abolition of Animal Exploitation. Columbia University Press, 2008. ISBN 978-0-231-13950-2
  • "Taking Sentience Seriously." Journal of Animal Law & Ethics 1, 2006.
  • "Animal Rights Theory and Utilitarianism: Relative Normative Guidance." Between the Species 3, 2003.
  • Introduction to Animal Rights: Your Child or the Dog?. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 2000. ISBN 1-56639-692-1
  • Rain without Thunder: The Ideology of the Animal Rights Movement. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1996. ISBN 1-56639-461-9
  • Animals, Property and the Law. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1995, ISBN 1-56639-284-5
  • "Personhood, Property and Legal Competence, in Paola Cavalieri & Peter Singer (eds.), The Great Ape Project. New York: St. Martin's Griffin, 1993, pp. 248–257.
  • (with Anna E. Charlton) Vivisection and Dissection in the Classroom: A Guide to Conscientious Objection. Jenkintown, Pa. : American Anti-Vivisection Society, 1992.

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ a b c "Gary L. Francione", Rutgers School of Law Newark, accessed February 25, 2008.
  2. ^ Francione, Gary. Animals as Persons: Essays on the Abolition of Animal Exploitation. Columbia University Press, 2008, back cover.
  3. ^ Hall, Lee. "An Interview with Professor Gary L. Francione", Friends of Animals, accessed February 25, 2008.
  4. ^ "Mission statement", abolitionistapproach.com, accessed 9 June 2012.
    • For the right not to be regarded as property, see Francione, Gary. Rain Without thunder: the Ideology of the Animal Rights Movement, 1996.
  5. ^ "Michael Marder and Gary Francione debate plant ethics". Columbia University Press.
  6. ^ Francione, Gary L. (2008-09-02). "What to Do on Proposition 2?". Newark, New Jersey: Animal Rights: The Abolitionist Approach. Archived from the original on 2012-11-29. Retrieved 2012-11-29. "... it is my view that animal advocates should vote against Proposition 2 ..." 
  7. ^ Francione, Gary (2006). "The Great Ape Project: Not so Great", Animal Rights: the Abolitionist Approach, accessed June 23, 2009.

Further reading[edit]


Wikipedia content is licensed under the GFDL License
Powered by YouTube
LEGAL
  • Mashpedia © 2014