Play Video
1
Is Obama
Is Obama's War On ISIS Legal?
::2014/09/22::
Play Video
2
War Powers in Practice (1 of 5)
War Powers in Practice (1 of 5)
::2009/11/09::
Play Video
3
Declare War Clause Song
Declare War Clause Song
::2013/11/24::
Play Video
4
John Stossel - War Powers
John Stossel - War Powers
::2013/09/19::
Play Video
5
Episode 1: Commerce vs. War - Why We Have a Commerce Clause
Episode 1: Commerce vs. War - Why We Have a Commerce Clause
::2012/03/25::
Play Video
6
The Most Important Cause of the Constitution: the Media vs. U.S. Constitution
The Most Important Cause of the Constitution: the Media vs. U.S. Constitution
::2012/10/26::
Play Video
7
Senator Whish-Wilson talks on the Greens War Powers Bill
Senator Whish-Wilson talks on the Greens War Powers Bill
::2014/09/03::
Play Video
8
Presidents at War: Presidential War Powers and the Challenges of Managing Wars
Presidents at War: Presidential War Powers and the Challenges of Managing Wars
::2014/06/19::
Play Video
9
Alert High Probability There Will Be A War Powers Act False Flag the X22Report Broadcast
Alert High Probability There Will Be A War Powers Act False Flag the X22Report Broadcast
::2013/08/28::
Play Video
10
Con Law: Legislative War Powers
Con Law: Legislative War Powers
::2012/02/25::
Play Video
11
Constitutional Law tutorial: Foreign Affairs and War Powers | quimbee.com
Constitutional Law tutorial: Foreign Affairs and War Powers | quimbee.com
::2014/03/06::
Play Video
12
Josh Earnest  Obama  Abuses the War Powers Act
Josh Earnest Obama Abuses the War Powers Act
::2014/09/14::
Play Video
13
War Powers
War Powers
::2009/10/17::
Play Video
14
The President Has Constitutional Power to Target and Kill U.S. Citizens Abroad
The President Has Constitutional Power to Target and Kill U.S. Citizens Abroad
::2014/03/06::
Play Video
15
Obama Violated US Constitution, Libya War is Abuse of Power & Betrayal of People
Obama Violated US Constitution, Libya War is Abuse of Power & Betrayal of People's Trust
::2011/08/01::
Play Video
16
Bigfoot   The Definitive Guide Full Documentary
Bigfoot The Definitive Guide Full Documentary
::2014/09/25::
Play Video
17
Article VI For Dummies: The Supremacy Clause Explained
Article VI For Dummies: The Supremacy Clause Explained
::2013/10/28::
Play Video
18
Why America Lost the Vietnam War (Full Documentary)
Why America Lost the Vietnam War (Full Documentary)
::2014/05/01::
Play Video
19
Obama has already crossed the line by violating the Constitution!
Obama has already crossed the line by violating the Constitution!
::2013/09/12::
Play Video
20
The Panic Is On
The Panic Is On
::2008/10/05::
Play Video
21
Rep. Rigell Joins Hardball with Chris Matthews to Discuss Reaffirming Congress
Rep. Rigell Joins Hardball with Chris Matthews to Discuss Reaffirming Congress' War Powers & Syria
::2013/06/18::
Play Video
22
Sen. Angus King Accuses Obama Admin of Rewriting Constitution by Waging Endless War
Sen. Angus King Accuses Obama Admin of Rewriting Constitution by Waging Endless War
::2013/05/17::
Play Video
23
Executive Power and the War on Terror
Executive Power and the War on Terror
::2008/01/31::
Play Video
24
Identity Unknown 1945 WWII MYSTERY - War Movies
Identity Unknown 1945 WWII MYSTERY - War Movies
::2014/05/01::
Play Video
25
Capitalism 15 - Expanded federal powers and the interstate commerce clause
Capitalism 15 - Expanded federal powers and the interstate commerce clause
::2011/09/10::
Play Video
26
World War 1 - The Great War - BBC Documentary - Episode 1
World War 1 - The Great War - BBC Documentary - Episode 1
::2014/05/01::
Play Video
27
Minesweeper 1943 WWII ACTION - Best War Movies
Minesweeper 1943 WWII ACTION - Best War Movies
::2014/05/01::
Play Video
28
WaPo
WaPo's Capehart Unfamiliar With Enumerated Powers Clause
::2012/08/02::
Play Video
29
The Vietnam War and President Nixon
The Vietnam War and President Nixon's Secret Escalation Strategy (Full Documentary)
::2014/05/01::
Play Video
30
Abuse of Power: 9/11, War and the Neocons
Abuse of Power: 9/11, War and the Neocons
::2013/01/01::
Play Video
31
Submarine Base 1943 WWII THRILLER - Best War Movies
Submarine Base 1943 WWII THRILLER - Best War Movies
::2014/05/01::
Play Video
32
"There Will Be War"- A-Kon 21- Saucy Noodle Cosplay
"There Will Be War"- A-Kon 21- Saucy Noodle Cosplay
::2010/06/13::
Play Video
33
The Last Nail - Floor Speech May 25 2011
The Last Nail - Floor Speech May 25 2011
::2011/05/25::
Play Video
34
Obama Violates the Fundamental Doctrine of the Constitution
Obama Violates the Fundamental Doctrine of the Constitution
::2013/07/08::
Play Video
35
Rep. Aaron Schock: Obama Already Has Congressional Authorization To Fight ISIL
Rep. Aaron Schock: Obama Already Has Congressional Authorization To Fight ISIL
::2014/09/15::
Play Video
36
B.A. American Government:  The Necessary and Proper (Elastic) Clause & McCulloch v. Maryland
B.A. American Government: The Necessary and Proper (Elastic) Clause & McCulloch v. Maryland
::2013/10/07::
Play Video
37
Constitutional Law tutorial: Dormant Commerce Clause | quimbee.com
Constitutional Law tutorial: Dormant Commerce Clause | quimbee.com
::2014/01/09::
Play Video
38
The Individual Mandate and the Commerce Clause
The Individual Mandate and the Commerce Clause
::2011/06/14::
Play Video
39
Thieves Robbed American People of Most Important Clause of the U.S. Constitution
Thieves Robbed American People of Most Important Clause of the U.S. Constitution
::2012/09/27::
Play Video
40
Women in the Night 1948 THRILLER - Best War Movies
Women in the Night 1948 THRILLER - Best War Movies
::2014/05/01::
Play Video
41
DAMN IT PEOPLE DON
DAMN IT PEOPLE DON'T YOU GET IT??? Part 5, The Order vs The Republic
::2011/12/20::
Play Video
42
Documentary Ottoman Empire The War Machine   History Documentary
Documentary Ottoman Empire The War Machine History Documentary
::2014/09/25::
Play Video
43
Impeach Obama for Syria War Plan NOW!
Impeach Obama for Syria War Plan NOW!
::2013/09/01::
Play Video
44
Then There Were Three 1961 WORLD WAR II ACTION - War Movies
Then There Were Three 1961 WORLD WAR II ACTION - War Movies
::2014/05/01::
Play Video
45
Express Powers And The Commerce Clause Doug V  Gibbs
Express Powers And The Commerce Clause Doug V Gibbs
::2013/01/19::
Play Video
46
Episode 2: Liberty vs. Tyranny - Limiting the Commerce Clause
Episode 2: Liberty vs. Tyranny - Limiting the Commerce Clause
::2012/03/25::
Play Video
47
Enumerated Powers vs. Unlimited Powers
Enumerated Powers vs. Unlimited Powers
::2014/07/03::
Play Video
48
John Kerry Lacks Integrity and Credibility
John Kerry Lacks Integrity and Credibility
::2013/08/28::
Play Video
49
The Last Chance 1945 WWII DRAMA - War Movies
The Last Chance 1945 WWII DRAMA - War Movies
::2014/05/01::
Play Video
50
World War 1 - The Great War - BBC Documentary - Episode 3
World War 1 - The Great War - BBC Documentary - Episode 3
::2014/05/01::
NEXT >>
RESULTS [51 .. 101]
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Article I, Section 8, Clause 11 of the United States Constitution, sometimes referred to as the War Powers Clause, vests in the Congress the power to declare war, in the following wording:

[The Congress shall have Power...] To declare War, grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal, and make Rules concerning Captures on Land and Water;

A number of wars have been declared under the United States Constitution, although there is some controversy as to the exact number, as the Constitution does not specify the form of such a declaration.

History and usage[edit]

Five wars have been declared by Congress under their constitutional power to do so: the War of 1812, the Mexican-American War, the Spanish-American War, World War I, and World War II.[1]

In a message to Congress on May 11, 1846, President James K. Polk announced that Texas was about to become a state. Consequentially, Mexico then threatened to invade Texas, upon which the President amassed troops in the area of Corpus Christi. Texas then became a state, and US troops moved into an area in which the new international boundary was disputed. Mexican troops moved into the same area, and the two forces clashed. The President then stated "after reiterated menaces, Mexico has passed the boundary of the United States, has invaded our territory and shed American blood upon the American soil. She has proclaimed that hostilities have commenced and that the two nations are now at war."[2] Some in Congress wondered if this were so, including Abraham Lincoln. He wrote in a letter to his law partner:

“Let me first state what I understand to be your position. It is, that if it shall become necessary, to repel invasion, the President may, without violation of the Constitution, cross the line and invade the territory of another country; and that whether such necessity exists in any given case, the President is to be the sole judge...But Allow the President to invade a neighboring nation, whenever he shall deem it necessary to repel an invasion, and you allow him to do so, whenever he may choose to say he deems it necessary for such purpose - and allow him to make war at pleasure…. If, to-day, he should choose to say he thinks it necessary to invade Canada, to prevent the British from invading us, how could you stop him? You may say to him, ‘I see no probability of the British invading us’ but he will say to you ‘be silent; I see it, if you don't.’

“The provision of the Constitution giving the war-making power to Congress, was dictated, as I understand it, by the following reasons. Kings had always been involving and impoverishing their people in wars, pretending generally, if not always, that the good of the people was the object. This our Convention understood to be the most oppressive of all Kingly oppressions; and they resolved to so frame the Constitution that no one man should hold the power of bringing this oppression upon us. But your view destroys the whole matter, and places our President where kings have always stood.”[3][4]

Then-congress member Lincoln moved for a Resolution issuing the President interrogatories (questions) so that Congress could determine for itself the exact "spot" of the conflict and whether the Congress believed it to be inside the United States.[5]

Regardless, Congress did, by roll-call vote, declare war. House Roll Call Vote, Senate Roll Call Vote, Published Declaration of War, 1, Published Declaration of War, 2

If it was true that the war was ongoing, because the President had to repel a sudden attack, this was contemplated by the framers of the Constitution, in Philadelphia, during August of the summer of 1787, when the wording of the proposed Constitution was being finalized, the draft read that Congress could "make war." This was changed to "declare war" specifically in order to allow the President to defend the country from sudden attacks. "Mr. Madison and Mr. Gerry moved to insert "declare," striking out "make" war; leaving to the Executive the power to repel sudden attacks."[6] The President taking decisive action to defend the country does not relieve Congress of its responsibility, and Congress is obligated to vote on whether to declare and continue the war.

American Presidents often have not sought formal declarations of war, instead maintaining that they have the Constitutional authority, as commander in chief (Article Two, Section Two) to use the military for "police actions". According to historian Thomas Woods, "Ever since the Korean War, Article II, Section 2 of the Constitution — which refers to the president as the 'Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States' — has been interpreted to mean that the president may act with an essentially free hand in foreign affairs, or at the very least that he may send men into battle without consulting Congress."[7]

The Korean War was the first modern example of the U.S. being taken to war without a formal declaration,[8] and this has been repeated in every armed conflict since. Beginning with the Vietnam War, however, Congress has given other various forms of authorization to do so. Some debate continues as to the appropriateness of these, as well as the tendency of the Executive Branch to engage in the origination of such a push, its marketing, and even propagandizing or related activities to generate such support.

Thus in light of the speculation concerning the Gulf of Tonkin Incident and the possible abuse of the authorization that followed, in 1973 Congress passed the War Powers Resolution, which requires the President to obtain either a declaration of war or a resolution authorizing the use of force from Congress within 60 days of initiating hostilities with a full disclosure of facts in the process. Its constitutionality has never been settled, and some Presidents have criticized it as an unconstitutional encroachment upon the President. In 2007, University of Virginia professor Larry J. Sabato proposed a Constitutional amendment in his book A More Perfect Constitution that would settle the issue by spelling out the exact powers of each branch in the Constitution itself. One counter-argument is that the Constitution is a "living document" which has survived for over 200 years because not everything is "spelled out." In the area of the War Powers Clause, the flexibility provided by the requirement for a Congressional statute permitting war (a declaration of war) and Constitutional interpretation could be sufficient. The President could defend the country, but not - by himself - use the military offensively. This would not require a Constitutional amendment or a statute like the War Powers Resolution; it has been with us since 1787.

Some legal scholars maintain that offensive, non-police military actions, while a Quorum can still be convened (see Continuity of Government), taken without a formal Congressional declaration of war is unconstitutional since no amendment with two-thirds majority of states has changed the original intent to make the War Powers Resolution legally binding. However, the Supreme Court has never ruled directly on the matter and to date no counter-resolutions have come to a vote. In the absence of a determination by the US Supreme Court, the Separation of Powers produces a stalemate on this issue.

Constitutional convention debate[edit]

As to the Philadelphia Convention and the intent of the American founders, there was only one delegate who suggested giving the Executive the power to take offensive military action: Pierce Butler of South Carolina.[9] He suggested the President should be able to, but in practice would have the character not to do so without mass support. Elbridge Gerry, a delegate from Massachusetts, summed up the majority viewpoint saying he "never expected to hear in a republic a motion to empower the Executive alone to declare war." George Mason, Thomas Jefferson, and others voiced similar sentiments.[10]

Supreme Court cases[edit]

Other Court cases[edit]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Congressional Power to Declare War". The people's Guide to the United States Constitution. The people's Guide to the United States Constitution. Retrieved 28 August 2013. 
  2. ^ WETA last visited 1/22/2011
  3. ^ Abraham Lincoln: a Documentary Portrait Through His Speeches and Writings. Don E. Fehrenbacher, editor., Stanford University Press, Stanford. CA (1996)
  4. ^ Lincoln on Democracy, Mario M. Cuomo and Harold Holzer (Fordham University Press, 2004) pp. 36-37.
  5. ^ http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=mal&fileName=mal1/000/0007000/malpage.db&recNum=0 last visited 1/21/2011
  6. ^ 2 Farrand Records 317
  7. ^ Woods, Thomas (2005-07-07) Presidential War Powers, LewRockwell.com
  8. ^ "The Constitution & War: Congress Declares & President Wages". www.ponderpost.com. PonderPost. Retrieved 1 September 2013. 
  9. ^ Fisher, Louis (April 10, 2008). "“War Powers for the 21st Century: The Constitutional Perspective”- Statement presented in appearance before the House Committee on Foreign Affairs". Library of Congress. Retrieved 2013-08-27. 
  10. ^ Max Rerrand, The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787 (rev. ed. 1937) at 318-219

Further reading[edit]

  • Fisher, Louis (2004) Presidential War Power, 2d Rev. Edition. University Press of Kansas
  • Hendrickson, Ryan C. The Clinton Wars: Congress, the Constitution and War Powers. Vanderbilt University Press, 2002
  • Lawson, Gary, "Delegation and Original Meaning" (October 2, 2001). Virginia Law Review, Vol. 88, April 2002
  • Madison, James. Federalist No. 45, The Federalist Papers
  • Woods, Thomas. Presidential War Powers, LewRockwell.com
  • Yoo, John C., "War and the Constitutional Text" . University of Chicago Law Review, Vol. 69, No. 4, Fall 2002
  • 2 Records of the Federal Convention of 1787, at 318-19 (Max Farrand ed. 1937).
Wikipedia content is licensed under the GFDL License
Powered by YouTube
LEGAL
  • Mashpedia © 2014